- Deadline
- 30 days from service of the notice (add 5 if served by certified mail)
- Who signs
- The plan administrator, under penalties of perjury
- Content
- All the facts alleged as reasonable cause
- If you miss it
- Facts deemed admitted; final order in 45 days
When to use it
Use this statement only after the DOL has served a notice of intent to assess a penalty under ERISA section 502(c)(2) for a late, missing or rejected annual report. Before the DOL writes, the cheaper route is the DFVCP. Once the notice arrives, that route is closed: “A Department of Labor Notice of Intent to Assess a Penalty will always disqualify a plan.”
The plan administrator signs. The statement goes to the DOL office and address given in the notice. The deadline is short: the administrator has “thirty (30) days from the date of service of the notice” to file it. For the full process, including the hearing that can follow, see DOL penalty notice for a late Form 5500. This template is a general starting point, not legal or tax advice: adapt it to your plan's facts, and have your advisor review it if the stakes are high. Using it does not guarantee any result. It does not make legal arguments; it gives you a place to set out the facts.
The statement
Template from form5500.org, based on 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(b)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR to (i); ERISA 502(c)(2); DOL DFVCP FAQs. Replace the highlighted text, check every line against your plan's facts, and delete this note before you use it.
Statement of Reasonable Cause
[Plan administrator name]
[Street address]
[City, state and ZIP code]
[Date]
[Name and address of the DOL office shown on the notice of intent to assess a penalty]
Re: Statement of reasonable cause under 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(e)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
Plan name: [Plan name]
Plan sponsor EIN: [EIN]
Plan number: [PN]
Plan year or years: [Plan years named in the notice]
Notice of intent to assess a penalty dated [Date of notice], reference [Case or reference number on the notice]
Date of service: [Date received, and whether by certified mail, regular mail or delivery in person]
Penalty proposed in the notice: $[Amount]
1. Purpose of this statement
[Plan administrator name], the administrator of the plan named above, files this statement of reasonable cause in response to the notice of intent to assess a penalty under section 502(c)(2) of ERISA. The administrator asks the Department to [not assess the penalty, or reduce the penalty] because of the facts set out below.
2. The annual report
The annual report for the plan year ending [Plan year end date] was due on [Original due date]. [An extension was, or No extension was] requested on Form 5558 [on date filed, or delete]. The report was filed through EFAST2 on [Date filed], acknowledgment ID [EFAST2 acknowledgment ID]. [If not yet filed: The report will be filed by date.]
3. Facts
[What happened, with dates. Describe each event that kept the report from being filed on time, in the order it happened.]
[Who was responsible for preparing and filing the report during this period, and what that person or firm did and when.]
[How these events prevented a timely filing.]
[What the administrator did once the cause ended, with the date of each step, through the date the report was filed.]
[The plan's filing history for other years, including any earlier late filings.]
[The steps taken so the report is filed on time in future years.]
4. Documents attached
• [Copy of the notice of intent to assess a penalty]
• [EFAST2 filing acknowledgment for the report]
• [Each document that supports a fact above, with its date]
5. Declaration
I declare under the penalties of perjury that I have examined this statement, including the attached documents, and to the best of my knowledge and belief the facts stated in it are true, correct and complete.
[Signature of the plan administrator]
[Printed name]
[Title, and the capacity in which you act as plan administrator]
[Date signed]
Contact for questions: [Name, phone and email]
How to fill it in
Put everything in writing, and put all of it in. The rule in 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(e) is that “Such statement must be made in writing and set forth all the facts alleged as reasonable cause for the reduction or nonassessment of the penalty.” Plan for one complete statement rather than a short letter followed by more later. Every fact you rely on belongs in section 3, with dates.
What the DOL weighs. Paragraph (d) lets the DOL decide not to assess all or part of the penalty on a showing that the administrator complied with the filing requirement, or “on a showing by the administrator of mitigating circumstances regarding the degree or willfulness of the noncompliance”. Paragraph (b)(1) says the amount is set “taking into consideration the degree and/or willfulness of the failure or refusal to file the annual report”. The six fact prompts in section 3 are there to make the timeline, the cause, and the speed of the fix clear. Leave out anything you cannot support.
The declaration. “The statement must contain a declaration by the administrator that the statement is made under the penalties of perjury.” Keep the declaration in section 5 and have the administrator sign it. If a firm acts as administrator, the person signing should state the capacity in which they sign.
The report itself. Under paragraph (b)(1), the penalty runs until “the date on which an annual report satisfactory to the Secretary is filed”. If the report is still unfiled, file it in EFAST2 as soon as you can and give the date in section 2. See how to file in EFAST2. For a rejected filing, paragraph (b)(3) treats a rejected report as not filed when a revised report is not filed within 45 days of the rejection notice.
Attachments. Attach a copy of the notice and the EFAST2 acknowledgment, plus anything that proves a date you give: letters, emails, medical or insurance records, or a service provider's correspondence. Plan lookup shows what the DOL's public data says about the plan's filings, which is worth checking before you describe the plan's history.
Timing and delivery
| Rule | What 29 CFR 2560.502c-229 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR says |
|---|---|
| Deadline | 30 days from the date of service of the notice, paragraph (e). |
| Service by certified mail | Service is complete on mailing, and 5 days are added to the time to file the statement, paragraph (i)(2). |
| Service by regular mail | Service is complete on receipt by the addressee, paragraph (i)(2). |
| Filing by USPS certified mail or Express Mail | The statement is filed on mailing, paragraph (i)(3)(i). |
| Filing by a designated private delivery service | Filed on receipt by the delivery service, paragraph (i)(3)(ii). |
| Any other method | Filed on receipt by the DOL at the address in the notice, paragraph (i)(3)(iv). |
The certified mail rule reads: “five (5) days shall be added to the time allowed by these rules for the filing of a statement”. Mail the statement by USPS certified mail or Express Mail and keep the receipt; then the mailing date is the filing date. Penalty days also stop for a while. Under paragraph (b)(2), if a statement is filed on time, no penalty is assessed from the date the DOL served the notice until the day after the DOL serves its determination.
Missing the 30 days is costly. The failure “shall be deemed an admission of the facts alleged in the notice” for any later proceeding, and the notice becomes a final order 45 days from service, under paragraph (f).
What happens next
The DOL reviews the facts and notifies the administrator in writing of its decision to waive the penalty in whole or in part, or to assess it. Any assessed amount cannot exceed the amount in the notice of intent (paragraph (g)(1)). That determination becomes a final order 45 days after service unless, within 30 days, the administrator files a request for a hearing and an answer under 29 CFR 2570.6029 CFR 2570.60Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR to 2570.71 (paragraph (h)). To see how administrative law judges have treated reasonable cause claims, read Form 5500 penalty decisions. The current maximum is $2,739 a day under ERISA 502(c)(2) (90 FR 185490 FR 1854Federal Register, govinfo, no 2026 adjustment); the penalties guide has the details.
Questions filers ask
How long do I have to file a statement of reasonable cause?
30 days from the date the DOL served the notice. If it was served by certified mail, service is complete on mailing and 5 days are added.
Who must sign the statement?
29 CFR 2560.502c-2(e)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR requires a declaration by the administrator that the statement is made under the penalties of perjury. A preparer can help gather the facts, but the declaration is the administrator's.
Does the penalty keep growing while the DOL reviews my statement?
Not for that period. If the statement is filed on time, no penalty is assessed from the date the notice was served until the day after the DOL serves its determination.
Can I still use the DFVCP after getting the notice?
No. The DFVCP FAQs say a DOL Notice of Intent to Assess a Penalty will always disqualify a plan.
Can the plan pay the penalty if it is assessed?
No. Under paragraph (j)(2), a person assessed under a final order is personally liable, and the DFVCP FAQs say these civil penalties cannot be paid from plan assets.
What if I do not answer the notice?
The facts in the notice are deemed admitted and the notice becomes a final order of the Secretary 45 days from service.