- Where these decisions come from
- The decisions
- How a judge reviews the penalty
- Reasonable cause: what has not worked
- Penalty amounts and reductions
- When the penalty starts
- Who is liable: the plan administrator
- Procedure: deadlines, settlements and defaults
- Appeal beyond the judge
- What the decisions mean for a filer
- Source
- OALJ ERISA benchbook, updated Jan. 15, 2021
- Cases in the table
- 24 annual report penalty decisions
- Standard of review
- De novo on facts, deferential on the amount
- Reasonable cause
- No lasting reduction in the cases described
- Appeal
- Notice of appeal within 20 days (29 CFR 2570.69)29 CFR 2570.69Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
Where these decisions come from
An administrator who contests a DOL penalty under ERISA 502(c)(2) can ask for a hearing before the DOL's Office of Administrative Law Judges (OALJ); the process is on the DOL penalty notice page. These cases carry the docket code RIS. In them, the OALJ says, the judge “determines the appropriateness of penalties imposed on administrators of employee benefit plans” for failing to meet ERISA's reporting and disclosure rules.
This page uses one source: the OALJ's own Judges' Deskbook on ERISA, “Updated January 15, 2021”. It summarizes rulings by judges and, on review, by PWBA and EBSA officials. We describe only what it says, and decisions after January 2021 are not covered. The OALJ keeps a list of RIS cases; read the full decision before relying on any case.
Most of these cases concern a missing audit report (the IQPA report), not a missing Form 5500. The regulation treats both alike: filing the required information only in part is a failure to file. See the audit requirement.
The decisions
Names and docket numbers are as the OALJ ERISA benchbook (January 2021) prints them, in order of decision. The year shows who decided: a judge (ALJ) or the PWBA or EBSA official who reviewed one.
| Case | Docket | Year | Argued | Held |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| USDOL v. Spalding and Evenflo Companies, Inc. | 1992-RIS-19 | 1994 (PWBA review) | Late audit reports; the judge counted from PWBA's first deficiency notice. | Reversed: the penalty starts the day after the original due date. |
| USDOL v. Northwestern Institute of Psychiatry | 1993-RIS-23 | 1995 (PWBA review) | The judge's role. | The judge hears evidence much like a court of original jurisdiction. |
| USDOL v. Optical Corp. of America | 1999-RIS-60 | 1999 (ALJ) | Hearing sought with no reasonable cause statement. | Dismissed: hearing waived, facts admitted. |
| USDOL v. Life Printing and Publishing Co. | 1999-RIS-49 | 1999 (ALJ) | Stipulation for dismissal filed the day before the hearing. | Rejected as late; PWBA offered no proof, so the penalty was reversed. |
| USDOL v. Compgraphix, Inc. | 1999-RIS-53 | 1999 (ALJ) | No audit: plan terminated, no funds, legal advice. | $50,000 upheld; the plan had cash for an audit. |
| USDOL v. Current Development Corp. | 1996-RIS-67 | 2000 (ALJ) | Settlement breached; penalty unpaid, Form 5500 late. | $198,000 fine upheld; $38,062 ordered. |
| USDOL v. Schneiderman's Furniture, Inc. | 2000-RIS-40 | 2001 (ALJ) | Remaining penalty after a late audit report. | $2,500 upheld after a 95 percent cut from $50,000. |
| USDOL v. Continue Care Holding Corp. | 2002-RIS-10 | 2003 (ALJ) | DOL moved to drop its $50,000 claim; respondent defunct. | Dismissed for lack of party. |
| USDOL v. Callaghan & Callaghan, Inc. | 2005-RIS-99 | 2006 (ALJ) | Accountant miscommunication; advice from an EBSA employee. | $2,167 upheld after a 95 percent cut from $43,350. |
| USDOL v. Dynapace Corp. | 2005-RIS-88 | 2007 (ALJ) | Fewer than 40 active employees, so no audit. | $86,500 upheld; with terminated participants the count exceeded 100. |
| USDOL v. Synergy Mfg. Technology, Inc. | 2005-RIS-20 | 2007 (ALJ) | Bankruptcy, officer death, staff departure; individual liability. | $50,000 upheld against the company; the individual not liable. |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, Stover Industries, Inc. | 2006-RIS-7 | 2007 (ALJ) | No audit report. | $44,400 penalty. |
| USDOL v. New Design Construction Co. | 2007-RIS-9 | 2007 (ALJ) | Letters not received; a DOL representative gave more time. | $5,545 upheld on summary judgment. |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator Arsenson Office Furnishings, Inc. p/s 401(K) Plan | 2007-RIS-111 | 2008 (ALJ) | Remaining penalty after a 95 percent abatement. | $2,500 affirmed. |
| USDOL v. Tile Finishers Local 88 NY, BAC Savings Plan | 2008-RIS-20 | 2008 (ALJ) | Audit report 530 days late. | $5,000 upheld. |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, Precision Wire Products, Inc. | 2007-RIS-141 | 2008 (ALJ) | Illness, death, trouble gathering audit data. | No reasonable cause; $6,000 abated penalty stood. |
| USDOL v. Product Mgt., Inc. | 2007-RIS-113 | 2009 (ALJ) | No audit report despite multiple DOL notices. | $50,000 affirmed. |
| USDOL, EBSA v. Plan Administrator, Dutch American Import Co., Inc., Employee Stock Ownership Plan | 2009-RIS-14 | 2012 (EBSA review) | Judge reduced the penalty for a report filed after the determination. | Reversed: not a mitigating circumstance. |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, Thibeault Corp. of NE/T-Quip Sales & Leasing 401(k) Plan | 2009-RIS-00068 | 2013 (EBSA review) | What a decision must contain. | Findings on each issue; penalty limited to 502(c)(2). |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, Cavallo Point Lodge 401(k) Plan | 2015-RIS-00025 | 2015 (ALJ) | Hearing sought with no reasonable cause statement. | No jurisdiction: the notice of intent was final. |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, Hago Manufacturing Co., Inc. Retirement Plan | 2013-RIS-00055 | 2017 (ALJ) | Standard of review and burden of proof. | De novo on facts, deferential on the amount. |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, DGA Inc. 401(k) Profit Sharing Plan | 2018-RIS-00072 | 2019 (ALJ) | No prehearing exchange or reply to a show cause order. | Default judgment (filing failure not described). |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, White Mountain Apache Tribe Retirement Savings and 401(k) Profit Sharing Plan | ALJ No. 2015-RIS-23 | 2019 (EBSA review) | Whether a tribal plan is exempt; discovery; good faith after a rejection. | Summary decision for EBSA affirmed on all three. |
| USDOL v. Plan Administrator, Gordon & Silver, Ltd. 401(k) Profit Sharing Plan | 2017-RIS-00031 | 2019 (ALJ) | Unopposed motion to affirm the penalty. | Summary decision against the respondent. |
The benchbook also describes a federal court case, Northwestern Institute of Psychiatry v. Martin, 1993 WL 52553 (E.D. Pa., Feb. 24, 1993), covered below.
How a judge reviews the penalty
In Hago Manufacturing (2017), the judge wrote that “OALJ’s standard of review in Section 502(c)(2) cases is de novo for fact-finding, but deferential for EBSA’s calculation of the penalty.” The DOL must prove the violation; the administrator must show the DOL did not properly weigh the degree and willfulness of the failure. In Dutch American Import (2012), the EBSA Director found “not a substantial basis in the decision of the ALJ for the ALJ to substitute her judgment as to the amount of the penalty for that of the DOL”, and held that a judge may not reduce a penalty without finding that the DOL abused its discretion.
Reasonable cause: what has not worked
The regulation does not define reasonable cause. In Compgraphix (1999), the judge quoted the 1989 preamble: “the Department anticipates that [ERISA section] 502(c) penalties will be waived to the extent that reasonable cause is demonstrated by the plan administrator.” In the cases the benchbook describes, these arguments failed:
| Argument | Case | Why it failed |
|---|---|---|
| Bankruptcy, a deceased officer, a departed comptroller | Synergy (2007) | Blaming them “would not demonstrate good faith or diligence in Respondent's performance of its duties as plan administrator” |
| Illness, death, trouble gathering information | Precision Wire (2008) | “Respondent mistakenly compares these obstacles of limited duration to an act of god like a hurricane” |
| No money for the audit; legal advice | Compgraphix (1999) | The plan had $13,853 in cash; the advice was second hand |
| Accountant errors; advice from an EBSA employee | Callaghan & Callaghan (2006) | ERISA “places responsibility for accurate, complete, and timely reporting on the plan administrator” |
| Fewer than 40 active employees | Dynapace (2007) | Counting terminated participants, over 100 |
| Filing after the notice of determination | Dutch American (2012) | “not relevant and cannot provide any basis for reducing the penalty.” |
| Letters never arrived | New Design (2007) | Not raised in the reasonable cause statement |
One ruling went the other way, in court. In Northwestern Institute of Psychiatry v. Martin, PWBA treated a statement filed without the perjury declaration as no statement. The court held these were two separate matters and that the missing declaration should not bar administrative review. Do not test that: sign the declaration, as the reasonable cause statement template does.
Penalty amounts and reductions
Where the benchbook gives a reason, the reductions came from the DOL before the hearing, after the administrator fixed the filing. In Callaghan & Callaghan, EBSA cut its $43,350 proposal by 95 percent to $2,167 once the audit report was filed, and the judge upheld the rest. Schneiderman's Furniture ($50,000 cut to $2,500), Arsenson ($2,500 after a 95 percent abatement) and Precision Wire ($6,000 abated) followed the same pattern. Where there was no compliance or no showing of good faith, larger amounts stood: $50,000 in Compgraphix, Synergy and Product Mgt., $86,500 in Dynapace. These were assessed years ago; today's ceiling is $2,739 a day (2025, 90 FR 185490 FR 1854Federal Register, govinfo; no 2026 adjustment, 91 FR 3135891 FR 31358Federal Register, govinfo). See Form 5500 penalties.
Amounts assessed years ago; today's ceiling is $2,739 a day (2025, 90 FR 185490 FR 1854Federal Register, govinfo; no 2026 adjustment). OALJ Judges' Deskbook: ERISA (updated Jan. 15, 2021).
When the penalty starts
In Spalding and Evenflo (1994), the judge counted from PWBA's first deficiency notice. The Senior Policy Advisor reversed: the penalty began the day after the original July 31, 1989 due date, because the compliance date is the “date that the annual report is due, not the date on which a PWBA reviewer first notes a failure or deficiency”. Extensions are ignored; see the Form 5500 due date.
Who is liable: the plan administrator
In Synergy (2007), the DOL asked to hold the individual who signed the Form 5500 as plan administrator liable too. The judge refused: refusing to settle was not evidence of avoiding liability, since “no one is required to settle a case”; the individual was not a party and had no proper notice; and the plan document was not in evidence. Under ERISA 3(16)(A), the administrator is the person the plan designates or, if none, the plan sponsor. In Compgraphix, the judge declined to pierce the corporate veil for lack of facts.
Procedure: deadlines, settlements and defaults
Missed deadlines end cases. In Optical Corp. of America (1999) and Cavallo Point Lodge (2015), no reasonable cause statement meant no hearing; in the second, the judge found “that OALJ does not have jurisdiction to adjudicate the issues presented because they were already determined in a final order”. In Life Printing (1999), a stipulation filed the day before the hearing broke the 5-day rule in 29 CFR 2570.6529 CFR 2570.65Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, and with no proof from PWBA the penalty was reversed. In Current Development (2000), a broken settlement put the parties back where they started. Ignoring the judge loses too: default judgment in DGA Inc. (2019) and an unopposed summary decision in Gordon & Silver (2019).
Appeal beyond the judge
Under 29 CFR 2570.69, a party may appeal to the Secretary of Labor “within twenty (20) days of the issuance of such decision”; otherwise the decision becomes final agency action. Review is on the record, without oral argument. The benchbook says “The Director of the Office of Policy and Research of the EBSA currently reviews these decisions.” It does not describe Administrative Review Board review of 502(c)(2) cases.
What the decisions mean for a filer
- Use the DFVCP before the DOL writes.
- Fix the filing fast. The 95 percent reductions followed compliance.
- Meet every 30-day deadline. A missed one ends the case.
- Put every fact in the reasonable cause statement.
- Do not blame others. ERISA puts the duty on the plan administrator.
Questions filers ask
Has anyone won a Form 5500 penalty case before an administrative law judge?
In the cases the January 2021 benchbook describes, the only respondent wins were a penalty reversed for lack of proof from PWBA (Life Printing), a case the DOL dropped (Continue Care), and an individual not held liable (Synergy).
Can a judge lower the DOL's penalty?
Only on a proper basis. In Dutch American Import the EBSA Director reversed a reduction made without a finding that the DOL abused its discretion.
Does filing the missing report after the notice of determination help?
Not under Dutch American Import. File before or with your reasonable cause statement.
Is a missing audit report treated like a late Form 5500?
Yes. A failure to file in whole or in part is a failure to file under 29 CFR 2560.502c-229 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR.
Where can I read decisions after January 2021?
The benchbook stops at January 15, 2021. The OALJ publishes a list of ERISA RIS cases on its website.