Where the audit requirement comes from
The audit is a statutory duty. ERISA section 103(a)(3)(A) says that, except as provided in subparagraph (C), “the administrator of an employee benefit plan shall engage, on behalf of all plan participants, an independent qualified public accountant”. The accountant examines the plan's financial statements and books and records, and the accountant's opinion becomes part of the annual report. The same paragraph gives the Department of Labor room to relieve small plans: where a plan is required only to file a simplified annual report, “the Secretary may waive the requirements of this paragraph”. The small-plan waiver in 29 CFR 2520.104-46 rests on that authority. The statute is at 29 U.S.C. 1023.
Small plan or large plan
Whether an audit is needed starts with the plan's size category. The 2025 instructions say a return/report filed for a plan that “covered 100 or more participants as of the beginning of the plan year should be completed following the requirements below for a “large plan.”” A plan with fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the year follows the small plan rules. The count is taken on the first day of the plan year.
Large plans attach Schedule H, and plans filing Schedule H generally must engage an IQPA and attach the IQPA's report under ERISA section 103(a)(3)(A). Small plans file Schedule I with the Form 5500, or the shorter Form 5500-SF if they qualify, and can claim the audit waiver if they meet its conditions. Which Form 5500 to file covers the form choice in detail.
| Small plan (fewer than 100) | Large plan (100 or more) | |
|---|---|---|
| Financial information | Schedule I, or Part III of the Form 5500-SF | Schedule H |
| IQPA report | Not required if the waiver conditions are met | Required and attached to the filing |
| Form 5500-SF | Available if every eligibility condition is met | Not available |
| Schedules C and G | Not filed | Filed when the instructions call for them |
| Audit waiver | Welfare plans: yes. Pension plans: if the 29 CFR 2520.104-46 conditions are met | Not available |
How to count participants
Defined contribution plans. For a 401(k), profit-sharing or other individual account plan, the count since the 2023 plan year is participants with account balances. The DOL's fact sheet on the 2023 changes says “The counting methodology for defined contribution retirement plans will be based on the number of participants with account balances”, rather than everyone who is eligible to participate. On the 2025 form, “A defined contribution pension plan uses the number required to be entered on line 6g(1)”: participants at the beginning of the plan year who have account balances. A plan that checks the first return/report box uses line 6g(2), the end-of-year number, instead.
The instructions give the 401(k) test for having an account: a participant counts on line 6g if they have made a contribution, or a contribution has been made for them, in this plan year or any prior plan year. An eligible employee who has never deferred and never received an employer contribution is counted on line 5 but not on line 6g.
Defined benefit plans. Defined benefit plans do not complete line 6g and use the line 5 total. For pension plans, a participant is an active participant, a retired or separated participant receiving benefits, a retired or separated participant entitled to future benefits, or a deceased individual whose beneficiaries are receiving or entitled to benefits. Alternate payees under a QDRO are not counted.
Welfare plans. Welfare plans also use line 5. An individual becomes a participant on the earliest of the date the plan designates, the date the individual becomes eligible for a benefit, or the date the individual makes a contribution. Former employees with continuation coverage under Part 6 of ERISA who are covered by the plan are included. Covered dependents are not counted. See Form 5500 for health and welfare plans for when a welfare plan files at all.
| Plan | Facts on January 1, 2025 | Count used | Category |
|---|---|---|---|
| 401(k) plan | 140 eligible employees, 92 with account balances | 92 (line 6g(1)) | Small |
| 401(k) plan | 180 eligible employees, 104 with account balances | 104 (line 6g(1)) | Large, unless the 80-120 rule applies |
| Defined benefit plan | 70 active, 25 separated vested, 10 retirees receiving benefits | 105 (line 5) | Large, unless the 80-120 rule applies |
Count each plan on its own. For welfare plans in particular, the instructions tell you to review the governing documents and actual operations to decide whether benefits are provided under one plan or several. Separate insurance policies do not by themselves mean separate plans.
The small-plan audit waiver
A small plan claims a waiver under 29 CFR 2520.104-46. The waiver relieves the administrator of engaging an IQPA, including the audited financial statements and schedules, and including the IQPA report. The rules differ for welfare and pension plans.
Small welfare plans. The waiver is automatic. The administrator of a welfare plan that covers fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year “is not required to comply with annual reporting requirements described in paragraph (c) of this section”, which is the list of audit items the waiver removes.
Small pension plans. A pension plan qualifies only if it meets three conditions for the year it claims the waiver:
- Qualifying plan assets or an enhanced bond. At least 95% of plan assets were qualifying plan assets as of the end of the preceding plan year, or every person who handles the non-qualifying assets is bonded under ERISA section 412 for at least the value of those assets.
- Enhanced SAR disclosure. The summary annual report (or the annual funding notice, for defined benefit plans that furnish one) names each regulated financial institution holding qualifying plan assets and the amount it reported at year end, names the surety company if more than 5% of assets are non-qualifying, tells participants they can examine or get copies of the bond and the institution statements free of charge, and tells them to contact EBSA if they cannot.
- Documents on request. When a participant or beneficiary asks, the administrator makes each regulated financial institution statement and evidence of any required bond available for examination, or furnishes copies, without charge.
Qualifying plan assets are, in summary: assets held by a bank or similar institution, a state-qualified insurance company, a registered broker-dealer or another organization authorized to act as an IRA trustee; mutual fund shares; insurance company investment and annuity contracts; participant-directed individual account assets for which the participant gets at least an annual statement from such an institution; qualifying employer securities; and participant loans that meet ERISA section 408(b)(1).
The regulation's own example shows how the 5% test works. Plan B has $600,000 of assets, of which “$558,000 constitutes “qualifying plan assets” and $42,000 constitutes non-qualifying plan assets”. Seven percent is more than 5%, so Plan B needs a fidelity bond of at least $42,000 covering the people who handle the non-qualifying assets. The bond has to cover all of the non-qualifying assets, not just the amount above 5%.
A small pension plan claims the waiver by answering Schedule I, line 4k, or line 6b of the Form 5500-SF. The 5500-SF route is narrower: a plan can use the short form only if it is eligible for the waiver “(but not by reason of enhanced bonding)”. A small plan that relies on the enhanced bond files the full Form 5500 with Schedule I.
The waiver removes the audit, not the filing. Under 29 CFR 2520.104-46(d)(1), a plan that claims the waiver still files its Form 5500 with the required schedules and statements.
Limited-scope audits under ERISA 103(a)(3)(C)
A limited-scope audit is still an audit; it narrows what the accountant has to cover. ERISA section 103(a)(3)(C) says the accountant's opinion “need not be expressed as to any statements required by subsection (b)(3)(G) prepared by a bank or similar institution or insurance carrier” that is regulated, supervised and subject to periodic examination by a state or federal agency, as long as the institution certifies those statements as accurate and they are made part of the annual report.
The DOL regulation at 29 CFR 2520.103-8 applies this to any plan whose assets are held by such a bank, similar institution or insurance carrier, for information certified under 29 CFR 2520.103-5. The 2025 instructions refer to this as an ERISA section 103(a)(3)(C) audit and add three points:
- The term “similar institution” does not include securities brokerage firms (DOL Advisory Opinion 93-21A), so a statement certified by a broker does not support this kind of audit.
- A related rule, 29 CFR 2520.103-12, lets the audit skip a plan's investment in a pooled fund that files its own audited Form 5500 as a 103-12 IE.
- Neither rule removes the audit itself: “Neither of these regulations exempt the plan administrator from engaging an IQPA nor from attaching the IQPA’s report to the Form 5500.”
On Schedule H, line 3b, the filer checks “DOL Regulation 2520.103-8,” “DOL Regulation 2520.103-12(d),” both, or box (3) if the audit was not performed under either. The type of opinion still goes on line 3a, and line 3a(1) for an unmodified opinion also covers the form of opinion that SAS 136 permits after a 103(a)(3)(C) audit with no modifications.
Rules that change the answer
- The 80-120 rule. A plan with between 80 and 120 participants at the beginning of the year may file in the same category, small or large, that it filed for the prior year. See the 80-120 rule. A plan that elects to stay large under that rule “may not claim a waiver under this section”.
- Short plan years. Under 29 CFR 2520.104-50, a plan may defer the IQPA report for the first of two consecutive plan years when one of them is a short plan year of seven months or less. The following year's Form 5500 is then filed as a large plan with Schedule H and accountant's reports for both years, whatever the participant count.
- Insured and unfunded welfare plans. 29 CFR 2520.104-44 covers welfare plans that pay benefits only from the employer's general assets, only through qualifying insurance contracts, or a mix of the two, if its conditions are met (for example, participant contributions forwarded within three months). Its own example is an insured welfare plan with 100 or more participants that files Form 5500 with Schedule A but is not required to engage an independent accountant. Such plans are also exempt from completing Schedule H.
- DCG reporting arrangements. Plans in a defined contribution group count participants at the individual plan level. Under the 2023 rules, a large plan in a DCG, or a small one that does not meet the waiver conditions, still needs its own plan-level audit.
To test your own plan, use the audit requirement checker.
If the accountant's report is missing
EFAST2 will take a large plan filing without the report, but the filing is incomplete. The instructions warn: “If the required IQPA’s report is not attached to the Form 5500, the filing is subject to rejection as incomplete and penalties may be assessed.” EFAST2 flags the gap with error P-204 when Schedule H shows assets or liabilities and no Accountant's Opinion attachment. The fix is an amended filing with the report attached. The DOL's civil penalty under ERISA 502(c)(2) can reach $2,739 a day (2025 amount, 90 FR 1854; no 2026 adjustment, 91 FR 31358); see Form 5500 penalties, and DFVCP if the filing is delinquent.
Questions filers ask
Does a 401(k) plan with 100 or more eligible employees need an audit?
Not necessarily. Since the 2023 plan year a defined contribution plan counts participants with account balances at the beginning of the plan year (line 6g(1)). If fewer than 100 people have balances, the plan is a small plan and can claim the waiver if it meets the conditions.
Is the count taken at the beginning or the end of the year?
The beginning of the plan year. The one exception is a defined contribution plan filing its first return/report, which uses the end-of-year number on line 6g(2).
Does a small welfare plan need an audit?
No. A welfare plan that covers fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year is covered by the waiver in 29 CFR 2520.104-46(b)(2) without further conditions. It may still have to file a Form 5500.
Can a plan be audited even if it qualifies for the waiver?
Yes. In its 2023 rulemaking (88 FR 11793) the DOL noted that plans may still conduct an audit when none is required.
Does a limited-scope audit mean we do not attach a report?
No. A 103(a)(3)(C) audit narrows the accountant's examination of certified investment information, but the plan still engages an IQPA and attaches the IQPA report.