The starting rule
Exemptions are exceptions to a broad rule. Every ERISA pension plan files, and the instructions are explicit that the return must be filed whether or not the plan is tax-qualified, “benefits no longer accrue, contributions were not made this plan year, or contributions are no longer made.” A plan files nothing only if it fits one of the categories below. If none fits, see which Form 5500 to file.
Plans ERISA excludes
ERISA section 4(b) (29 U.S.C. 1003(b)) takes five kinds of plans out of Title I altogether, and the 2025 instructions list each one as a plan that does not file:
| Plan | Note |
|---|---|
| Governmental plan | Pension and welfare plans. The instructions list governmental plans under both. |
| Church plan | A church pension plan files only if it elected coverage under Code section 410(d). A church welfare plan under ERISA section 3(33) does not file. |
| Workers' compensation, unemployment or disability insurance plan | Only if maintained solely to comply with those laws. |
| Plan maintained outside the U.S. | Primarily for persons substantially all of whom are nonresident aliens. Certain foreign pension plans still file Form 5500-EZ with the IRS. |
| Unfunded excess benefit plan | See ERISA section 4(b)(5). |
A church pension plan that elects coverage under Code section 410(d) is on the filing list: the instructions name church pension plans electing coverage under section 410(d) among the pension plans that must file.
Small unfunded and insured welfare plans
This is the exemption most employers rely on. Under 29 CFR 2520.104-20, the instructions say do not file for “A welfare benefit plan that covered fewer than 100 participants as of the beginning of the plan year and is unfunded, fully insured, or a combination of insured and unfunded”, and that is not subject to the Form M-1 requirements. Each word in that test carries a condition:
- Fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year. The count at year end does not matter. The regulation's own example: a plan with 75 participants at the start and 105 at the end stays exempt. “The exemption provided by § 2520.104-20 applies even though the plan has more than 100 participants by the end of the plan year”.
- Unfunded means benefits are paid as needed from the employer's or employee organization's general assets. “Plans that are NOT unfunded include those plans that received employee (or former employee) contributions during the plan year and/or used a trust or separately maintained fund”, including a 501(c)(9) trust.
- Fully insured means benefits come only through insurance contracts from an insurer (or HMO) qualified to do business in a state, with premiums paid directly to the carrier, and any employee contributions forwarded within three months of receipt.
- Insured plans with refunds must return participants' share of refunds within three months and tell participants about the refund allocation when they enter the plan.
- Not a MEWA filer. The instructions say plans required to file a Form M-1 are not eligible for this exemption. “Such plans are required to file the Form 5500 regardless of the plan size or type of funding.”
Employee contributions through a cafeteria plan get special treatment. A welfare plan with employee contributions that is associated with a Code section 125 cafeteria plan may be treated as unfunded for annual reporting if it meets DOL Technical Release 92-01, and COBRA or other after-tax contributions received by the cafeteria plan do not by themselves end that relief.
The exemption covers annual reporting, not everything. The regulation says it “does not exempt the administrator of an employee benefit plan from any other requirement of title I of the Act”, including the summary plan description. For counting participants in a welfare plan, see Form 5500 for health and welfare plans.
Large insured welfare plans still file
At 100 or more participants, the same unfunded or insured welfare plan must file a Form 5500, with reduced content. 29 CFR 2520.104-44 relieves it of the audit and the financial statements, but “This section does not exempt any plan from filing an annual report form with the Secretary”. The regulation's example: an insured welfare plan that fails the 2520.104-20 exemption only because it covers 100 or more participants files a Form 5500 with Schedule A, but does not engage an accountant. The instructions' quick reference chart adds that such a plan must still complete Schedule G, Part III, for any nonexempt transactions.
Top hat plans
A top hat plan is an unfunded (or insured) plan an employer maintains primarily for a select group of management or highly compensated employees. Pension and welfare versions are treated differently.
Top hat pension plans (deferred compensation). Under 29 CFR 2520.104-23, the administrator satisfies the reporting rules with a one-time statement to the DOL instead of an annual Form 5500. The statement gives the employer's name, address and EIN, “a declaration that the employer maintains a plan or plans primarily for the purpose of providing deferred compensation for a select group of management or highly compensated employees”, and the number of such plans and employees in each. Key rules:
- One statement covers all of an employer's top hat pension plans.
- For a new plan, “the statement shall be filed within 120 days after the plan becomes subject to part 1.”
- It is filed electronically, following the DOL's published instructions.
- The administrator must provide plan documents to the DOL on request.
- Benefits must be paid solely from the employer's general assets, through insurance contracts the employer pays for from its general assets, or both.
The 2025 instructions tie the exemption to the statement: the plan must meet the regulation “including timely filing of a registration statement with the DOL.” A top hat pension plan that never filed the statement does not have the exemption.
Top hat welfare plans. Under 29 CFR 2520.104-24, an unfunded or insured welfare plan for the same select group is exempt from reporting and disclosure entirely, “except for providing plan documents to the Secretary of Labor upon request”. No statement is filed.
SEPs, SIMPLE IRAs, IRAs and some 403(b)s
The 2025 instructions list these pension arrangements as not filing:
- A SEP or salary reduction SEP under Code section 408(k) that follows the alternative method of compliance in 29 CFR 2520.104-48 or 29 CFR 2520.104-49.
- A SIMPLE plan that involves SIMPLE IRAs under Code section 408(p).
- An individual retirement account or annuity not considered a pension plan under 29 CFR 2510.3-2(d).
- A 403(b)(1) annuity or 403(b)(7) custodial account arrangement not established or maintained by an employer, as described in 29 CFR 2510.3-2(f).
Be careful with the last item. A 403(b) plan that is established or maintained by the employer is covered by Title I and files. So do employer IRAs under Code section 408(c) and 401(k) plans that use the SIMPLE provisions of Code section 401(k)(11): both are on the instructions' list of plans that must file. See Form 5500 for a 401(k) plan.
Owner-only plans
A one-participant pension plan (owners, partners and their spouses only) does not file a Form 5500, but it may owe a Form 5500-EZ to the IRS once its combined assets pass $250,000 or in its final year. See Form 5500-EZ for one-participant plans. A welfare plan maintained only for an owner (and spouse) or for partners (and spouses) does not file at all, because under 29 CFR 2510.3-3 those individuals are not employees.
Other listed exemptions
| Plan | Condition | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Apprenticeship or training plan | Provides only apprenticeship or training benefits and files a notice with the DOL with the plan name, sponsor EIN, administrator and where to get course information | 29 CFR 2520.104-22 |
| Unfunded dues financed welfare or pension plan | Maintained by an employee organization, paid from general assets derived from dues; files Form LM-2 or LM-3 instead | 29 CFR 2520.104-26, 29 CFR 2520.104-27 |
| Welfare plan in a group insurance arrangement | The trust or other entity holding the group insurance contracts files a Form 5500 for the plan | 29 CFR 2520.104-43 |
The group insurance arrangement exemption has a limit worth noting: under 29 CFR 2520.104-43(c), the plan administrator must still furnish a summary annual report to participants and beneficiaries.
Summary table
| Plan | Files Form 5500? |
|---|---|
| Governmental plan | No |
| Church plan, no 410(d) election | No |
| Church pension plan with a 410(d) election | Yes |
| Welfare plan, under 100 at start of year, unfunded or fully insured, no M-1 | No |
| Same plan, 100 or more participants | Yes, without an audit (29 CFR 2520.104-44) |
| Welfare plan using a trust or receiving employee contributions outside a cafeteria plan | Yes |
| Plan required to file Form M-1 | Yes, any size |
| Top hat pension plan with a timely DOL statement | No |
| Top hat welfare plan, unfunded or insured | No |
| SEP (alternative method) or SIMPLE IRA plan | No |
| Employer 403(b) plan covered by Title I | Yes |
| One-participant pension plan | No Form 5500; Form 5500-EZ if over $250,000 combined or final year |
Questions filers ask
Our health plan is fully insured and has 60 employees enrolled. Do we file?
Not if it covered fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year, premiums go directly to the insurer, employee contributions are forwarded within three months, and the plan is not required to file a Form M-1. Count participants, not just employees, under the welfare plan counting rules.
We pay claims through a trust. Is the plan still unfunded?
No. The instructions say a plan that used a trust or separately maintained fund, including a 501(c)(9) trust, to hold or pass through plan assets is not unfunded. It files even if it is small.
Does a top hat plan file a new statement every year?
No. The regulation calls for one statement per employer, covering all of its top hat pension plans, filed within 120 days after a plan becomes subject to part 1. Plan documents must be provided to the DOL on request.
Is a SIMPLE 401(k) exempt like a SIMPLE IRA?
No. The exemption covers SIMPLE plans that use SIMPLE IRAs under Code section 408(p). A 401(k) plan using the SIMPLE provisions of section 401(k)(11) is on the list of plans that must file.
We crossed 100 participants in the middle of the year. Do we lose the small welfare plan exemption?
Not for that year. The test is the count at the beginning of the plan year. The regulation's example of 75 participants at the start and 105 at the end stays exempt. Recount at the start of the next plan year.