The three forms
The starting rule is broad. The instructions say “A return/report must be filed every year for every pension benefit plan, welfare benefit plan, and for every entity that files as a DFE”. Which return a plan uses depends on who it covers, how big it is, and what it holds.
| Form | Who uses it | Where it goes |
|---|---|---|
| Form 5500 | Large plans, and small plans that do not qualify for the 5500-SF. Filed with the schedules that apply. | EFAST2, electronic only |
| Form 5500-SF | Small plans that meet every eligibility condition in the 5500-SF instructions. | EFAST2, electronic only |
| Form 5500-EZ | One-participant plans (owners, partners and their spouses) and certain foreign plans. | IRS on paper, or EFAST2 |
| None | Plans exempt under ERISA or a DOL regulation, and small one-participant plans under the asset threshold. | Nothing to file |
The which form checker runs the same questions as this page and gives an answer for one plan.
Step 1: Is the plan exempt?
Check the exemptions first, because an exempt plan files no Form 5500 of any kind. The common ones are governmental plans, church plans that have not elected coverage under Code section 410(d), small welfare plans that are unfunded or fully insured, top hat plans that use the DOL alternative method, SEPs and SIMPLE IRA plans. The full list, with the conditions for each, is on plans that do not file Form 5500.
An exemption is not the same as having no assets or no contributions. A plan that is frozen, unfunded for the year or not tax-qualified still files unless a specific exemption applies.
Step 2: One-participant or foreign plan
Form 5500-EZ is a separate track. The EZ instructions say “Form 5500-EZ is used by one-participant plans and foreign plans that are not subject to the requirements of section 104(a) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA).” A one-participant plan is a retirement plan that covers only the business owner (or the owner and spouse) who own the whole business, or only partners (or partners and spouses). A 2% shareholder of an S corporation is treated as a partner, and an ESOP does not count as a one-participant plan.
These plans have no choice of form. The instructions say a one-participant plan or foreign plan “cannot file an annual return on Form 5500, Annual Return/Report of Employee Benefit Plan, or Form 5500-SF, Short Form Annual Return/Report of Small Employee Benefit Plan, regardless of whether the plan previously filed an annual return on Form 5500 or Form 5500-SF.” The IRS Form 5500 Corner puts it plainly: “You can no longer use Form 5500-SF in place of Form 5500-EZ.”
A one-participant plan does not have to file for 2025 if the assets of all the employer's one-participant plans combined are $250,000 or less at the end of the plan year, unless 2025 is the plan's final year. The details, including foreign plans and the late filer program, are on Form 5500-EZ for one-participant plans.
Step 3: Small plan or large plan
For every other plan, size decides the next step. The Form 5500 instructions say “If you are a small plan (generally under 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year), you may be eligible to file the Form 5500-SF instead of the Form 5500.” A plan with 100 or more participants at the beginning of the plan year is a large plan.
The count you use depends on the plan type:
- Defined benefit plans and welfare plans use the participant count on Form 5500, line 5 (participants at the beginning of the plan year).
- Defined contribution plans use line 6g(1): participants at the beginning of the year who have account balances.
- A defined contribution plan filing its first return uses line 6g(2), the participants with account balances at the end of the year.
Two exceptions can keep a plan in the small category. Under the 80-120 rule, if the count is between 80 and 120 and a return was filed for the prior year, the plan may file in the same category as the prior year, including the 5500-SF if it qualifies. Under the short plan year rule, a plan with a short year of seven months or less can elect to defer the accountant's report under 29 CFR 2520.104-50. Size also drives the audit: see the Form 5500 audit requirement.
Step 4: The Form 5500-SF conditions
A small plan does not get the short form automatically. The 5500-SF instructions say you “may file the Form 5500-SF instead of the Form 5500 only if you meet all of the eligibility conditions listed below.” For 2025 the eight conditions are:
- The plan covered fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the 2025 plan year, or filed as a small plan for 2024 under the 80-120 rule and covered no more than 120 participants at the beginning of 2025.
- The plan held no employer securities at any time during the plan year.
- At all times during the year, 100% of the plan's assets were “eligible plan assets”: for example mutual fund shares, insurance company and bank investment contracts valued at least annually, publicly traded securities held by a registered broker-dealer, cash and cash equivalents, and participant loans.
- The plan is eligible for the small plan audit waiver under 29 CFR 2520.104-46, but not by reason of enhanced bonding.
- The plan is not a multiemployer plan.
- The plan is not required to file a Form M-1 (the MEWA report) for the plan year.
- The plan is not a pooled employer plan.
- The plan is not filing as, or as part of, a DCG reporting arrangement.
The instructions add: “Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) and Direct Filing Entities (DFEs) (including DCGs) may not file the Form 5500-SF.”
The audit waiver condition trips up the most filers. A small pension plan qualifies for the 5500-SF only if it meets the waiver with 95% or more of its assets in qualifying plan assets. If the plan instead relies on an enhanced fidelity bond, “the plan does not satisfy the conditions for filing the Form 5500-SF and must file the Form 5500”, with its schedules. Small welfare plans are exempt from the audit requirement by their size.
Qualifying plan assets (for the audit waiver) and eligible plan assets (for the 5500-SF) are not the same thing. The SF instructions give an example: real estate held by a bank as trustee can be a qualifying plan asset, but it is not an eligible plan asset, because it has no readily determinable fair market value. A plan holding it files the Form 5500.
A small plan that qualifies still attaches some schedules to the 5500-SF: single-employer defined benefit plans file Schedule SB, money purchase plans amortizing a funding waiver file Schedule MB, and multiple-employer plans file Schedule MEP.
Everyone else: Form 5500 and schedules
Large plans, and small plans that fail any 5500-SF condition, file the Form 5500 with the schedules that apply. Large plans file Schedule H and generally attach the report of an independent qualified public accountant (IQPA). Small plans that file the Form 5500 rather than the 5500-SF file Schedule I. Schedule A goes with any plan that provides benefits through an insurance company, and Schedules C, D, G, MB, MEP, R and SB apply depending on the plan and what it holds.
Some large plans get relief without changing forms. A welfare plan with 100 or more participants that is unfunded, fully insured or a combination still files a Form 5500, but under 29 CFR 2520.104-44 it does not engage an IQPA or complete Schedule H. Fully insured pension plans that meet 29 CFR 2520.104-44(b)(2) get similar relief. For welfare plans in detail, see Form 5500 for health and welfare plans.
E-file or paper
For the Form 5500 and the 5500-SF there is no paper option. The instructions say “Your 2025 Form 5500 must be electronically filed in the ERISA Filing Acceptance System (EFAST2).” The 5500-SF instructions say the same for the short form. You can file through EFAST2's web-based system (IFILE) or approved software. See how to file in EFAST2.
Form 5500-EZ is the one form with a choice. It can be mailed to the IRS in Ogden, Utah, or filed through EFAST2. That choice ends for many filers under the IRS mandatory e-filing rule: for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, a filer that must file at least 10 returns of any type with the IRS during the calendar year that includes the first day of the plan year must file the 5500-EZ electronically. Forms W-2 and 1099, income tax, employment tax and excise tax returns all count toward the 10. The instructions warn: “If a filer is required to file a Form 5500-EZ electronically but does not, the filer is considered to have not filed the form even if a paper Form 5500-EZ is submitted.”
All three forms share the same deadline: the last day of the 7th calendar month after the plan year ends. See Form 5500 due date.
Quick decision chart
| Your plan | What to file |
|---|---|
| Exempt under ERISA section 4(b) or a DOL regulation (for example a governmental plan or a small fully insured welfare plan) | Nothing |
| One-participant plan, all one-participant plans combined at $250,000 or less at year end, not the final year | Nothing |
| One-participant plan over $250,000 combined, or in its final year | Form 5500-EZ |
| Foreign plan required to file under Code section 6058(a) | Form 5500-EZ |
| Small plan that meets all 8 SF conditions | Form 5500-SF (plus SB, MB or MEP if they apply) |
| Small plan that fails any SF condition | Form 5500 with Schedule I and other schedules |
| Large plan (100 or more, or over 120 under the 80-120 rule) | Form 5500 with Schedule H and, generally, an IQPA report |
| ESOP, multiemployer plan, pooled employer plan, DFE, or a plan that must file Form M-1 | Form 5500 |
Questions filers ask
Can a small plan choose to file the full Form 5500 instead of the 5500-SF?
Yes. The SF instructions say a plan that meets the conditions may file the 5500-SF; it is an option, not a requirement. A plan that files the Form 5500 as a small plan completes Schedule I and the other schedules that apply.
My solo 401(k) filed a 5500-SF years ago. Can I keep using it?
No. A one-participant plan files Form 5500-EZ regardless of what it filed before. If the plan now covers employees, it is no longer a one-participant plan and files the Form 5500 or 5500-SF.
Does a plan with a self-directed brokerage account qualify for the 5500-SF?
Only if every asset meets the definition of eligible plan assets at all times during the year. Publicly traded securities held by a registered broker-dealer qualify; assets without a readily determinable fair market value, such as real estate, do not.
We crossed 100 participants this year. Do we have to switch to the full Form 5500?
Not always. If the count at the beginning of the year is 120 or less and the plan filed as a small plan last year, the 80-120 rule lets it keep filing as a small plan, including the 5500-SF if it still meets the other conditions.
Is the 5500-SF filed with the IRS or the DOL?
Neither by paper. It is filed electronically through EFAST2. The IRS, DOL and PBGC consolidated their annual return forms, and the SF instructions say filers “generally will satisfy their IRS and DOL annual reporting requirements” by filing the Form 5500, 5500-SF or 5500-EZ.