Late filing, penalties and relief

DOL penalty notice for a late Form 5500: reasonable cause statement and hearing

Before the DOL assesses a penalty for a late or deficient Form 5500, it sends the plan administrator a notice of intent to assess. You have 30 days from service to file a written statement of reasonable cause made under penalty of perjury, and 30 more days after the DOL's determination to file an answer asking for a hearing before an administrative law judge. Once the notice arrives, the DFVCP is no longer available.

Updated November 20, 2026Sources ERISA 502(c)(2); 29 CFR 2560.502c-2; 29 CFR 2570.60 to 2570.71; OALJ sample answer; DOL DFVCP FAQs; 90 FR 1854; 91 FR 31358

What the notice of intent is

The DOL cannot assess a Form 5500 penalty without warning. The regulation, 29 CFR 2560.502c-2, says that before any assessment the DOL must give the administrator “a written notice indicating the Department's intent to assess a penalty under section 502(c)(2), the amount of such penalty, the period to which the penalty applies, and the reason(s) for the penalty”. That letter is the notice of intent to assess a penalty. Read it for three things: the dollar amount, the plan years and days it covers, and the reason.

The notice goes to the plan administrator, the person liable. A failure to file covers filing the required information only in part, so a Form 5500 filed on time without its required audit report (the IQPA report) can draw the same notice as no filing at all. Most of the cases in the OALJ benchbook are about a missing audit report; see Form 5500 penalty decisions. The notice often follows a letter rejecting the filing; see rejected and deficient filings.

Every deadline runs from service. The DOL can deliver the notice, leave it at the administrator's office or residence, or mail it to the last known address. Certified mail service is complete on mailing; regular mail service is complete on receipt.

How much the DOL can assess

ERISA section 502(c)(2) (29 U.S.C. 1132(c)(2)) allows a civil penalty against any plan administrator “of up to $1,000 a day from the date of such plan administrator’s failure or refusal to file the annual report”. The $1,000 is adjusted for inflation. For penalties assessed after January 15, 2025, the DOL's 2025 adjustment rule (90 FR 1854) raised the ERISA 502(c)(2) maximum, listed at 29 CFR 2575.1-3, from $2,670 to $2,739 a day. There is no 2026 increase: the DOL's May 27, 2026 rule (91 FR 31358)91 FR 31358Federal Register, govinfo says the October 2025 price data was never published, so “the 2026 adjustment is cancelled entirely”.

The amount is set by the DOL “taking into consideration the degree and/or willfulness of the failure or refusal to file the annual report”. It runs from the original due date, ignoring any extension, up to the date a satisfactory report is filed. The DOL's DFVCP FAQs describe the working amounts it uses outside the program: late filers may be assessed $50 a day with no limit, and non-filers $300 a day, up to $30,000 a year, until a complete report is filed. Those are DOL practice, not ceilings in the regulation. See Form 5500 penalties for the IRS penalties that can apply on top.

Why the DFVCP is closed now

The DFVCP caps the DOL penalty for late filers who come forward on their own, but only before the DOL writes. The 2002 program notice makes it available only to an administrator who files before the DOL notifies the administrator in writing of a failure to file a timely annual report. The DOL FAQs draw the line plainly: “An IRS late-filer letter will not disqualify a plan from participating in the DFVCP.” But “A Department of Labor Notice of Intent to Assess a Penalty will always disqualify a plan.” The DOL's program page lists the same notice among the reasons a plan cannot use it.

Losing the DFVCP also costs the automatic IRS relief. Under Notice 2014-35, the IRS relief covers Title I retirement plans that “are eligible for DOL’s DFVCP” and that satisfy every DFVCP requirement. A plan that has a DOL notice of intent cannot meet that condition, so any IRS penalty has to be handled with the IRS separately. See IRS relief for DFVC filers.

If the DOL has not yet written to you about a late Form 5500, the DFVCP and its capped amounts are still open to you. Once a notice of intent arrives, the only path is the one on this page.

The process, step by step

  1. The due date passes. The clock starts on the original due date, ignoring any Form 5558 extension.
  2. The DOL may reject a deficient filing. You get 45 days to file a satisfactory revised report.
  3. The DOL serves a notice of intent. It states the amount, period and reasons. The DFVCP is now closed.
  4. You file a statement of reasonable cause within 30 days. No penalty accrues from service of the notice until the day after the DOL serves its determination.
  5. The DOL issues a notice of determination. It waives or assesses, never more than the notice of intent.
  6. You file a hearing request and answer within 30 days. Filing the answer starts the OALJ proceeding.
  7. An administrative law judge decides. The case can settle, end on summary decision, or go to hearing.
  8. Either side may appeal within 20 days. Without an appeal, the decision becomes final agency action. A person assessed under a final order is personally liable.

Every deadline in one table

Each period runs from the date of service of the notice, not the date on the letter. Add 5 days to the reasonable cause and hearing periods when the DOL served the notice by certified mail.

EventDeadlineIf you miss itRule
DOL notice of rejection of a deficient report45 days to file a satisfactory revised reportThe report is treated as not filed29 CFR 2560.502c-2(b)(3)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
Notice of intent to assess a penalty served30 days to file a statement of reasonable causeFacts admitted, right to contest waived; the notice becomes a final order 45 days from service29 CFR 2560.502c-2(e)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, (f)
Notice of determination served30 days to file a request for hearing and an answerFacts admitted; the determination becomes a final order 45 days from service29 CFR 2560.502c-2(g)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, (h); 2570.64
Service by certified mailAdd 5 days to the statement or the hearing request period29 CFR 2560.502c-2(i)(2)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
Settlement before a hearingJoint motion to defer at least 5 days before the hearing dateThe judge may refuse a late stipulation29 CFR 2570.65(a)29 CFR 2570.65Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, (c)
Hearing transcript filed20 days to file proposed findings, if the judge allows29 CFR 2570.68(a)29 CFR 2570.68Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
Judge's decision issued20 days to file a notice of appeal to the SecretaryThe decision becomes final agency action29 CFR 2570.69(a)29 CFR 2570.69Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR

Do not count on more time. In one case the benchbook describes, the judge pointed to warnings in bold print in the notice of rejection and the notice of intent “that no extension would be allowed as the law does not allow for extensions of time to respond”.

Writing the reasonable cause statement

The statement is your one chance to put facts in front of the DOL before it decides. Under 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(e)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR it must explain why the penalty, as calculated, should be reduced or not assessed. It “must be made in writing and set forth all the facts alleged as reasonable cause for the reduction or nonassessment of the penalty”, and “The statement must contain a declaration by the administrator that the statement is made under the penalties of perjury.”

The DOL can waive all or part of the penalty on two grounds only: that the administrator complied, or mitigating circumstances regarding the degree or willfulness of the noncompliance. Build the statement around them:

  1. Fix the filing first. File what is missing in EFAST2 and give the date. In several cases the benchbook describes, the DOL cut the proposed penalty by 95 percent after the administrator came into compliance.
  2. Give dated facts and records. What happened, when, what you did, and why it was not willful.
  3. Put everything in now. In one case the judge would not credit a claim that was not in the earlier reasonable cause statement.
  4. Sign the perjury declaration. The administrator signs it.
  5. File it in a way you can prove. It counts as filed on mailing by USPS certified mail or Express Mail, on delivery to a designated private delivery service, or otherwise on receipt by the DOL.

Illness, a death, staff departures, bankruptcy, confusion over the due date and reliance on an accountant have not worked before the judges; see the decisions page. A starting point is the reasonable cause statement template.

Requesting a hearing: the answer

If the DOL's determination still assesses a penalty, you have 30 days from its service to ask for a hearing. The regulation requires two things in that window: a request for a hearing under 29 CFR 2570.6029 CFR 2570.60Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR to 2570.71, and an answer to the notice. “The answer opposing the proposed sanction shall be in writing, and supported by reference to specific circumstances or facts surrounding the notice of determination” issued under paragraph (g).

The OALJ's own sample answer page says the same in practical terms. To request a hearing on a notice of determination, a party must file an answer, and the answer must “include arguments opposing the proposed sanction supported by reference to specific circumstances or facts surrounding the basis for EBSA's determination letter”. The OALJ sample, which shows form and format only, runs in this order: a caption naming EBSA as complainant and the administrator as respondent; numbered paragraphs on the plan, the notice of intent, the timely reasonable cause statement and the determination; a statement that the answer is filed under 29 CFR 2570.6229 CFR 2570.62Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR seeking the hearing in 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(h)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR; the explanations and defenses; the relief sought; a signature; and a certificate of service.

Under 29 CFR 2570.62, documents are filed with the OALJ's Chief Docket Clerk, a copy goes to every party, and the Department is served through the Associate Solicitor, Plan Benefits Security Division. The person serving a document must certify how and when it was served. The addresses in that section date from its 1991 amendment, so confirm the current address with the OALJ before you file. The rules direct that proceedings move as quickly as possible.

What happens if you do nothing

Silence is treated as agreement. If no reasonable cause statement is filed within 30 days, that failure “shall be deemed to constitute a waiver of the right to appear and contest the facts alleged in the notice of intent”, the facts are deemed admitted, and the notice becomes a final order 45 days from service. The same rule applies one stage later: under 29 CFR 2570.64, a respondent who files no answer to the notice of determination within 30 days waives the right to contest it, and the notice becomes the final order of the Secretary 45 days from service.

The judges enforce this. In a 2015 case a missed reasonable cause statement made the notice of intent final, and the judge found the OALJ had no jurisdiction to hear the case. A respondent who answers but then ignores the judge's orders can lose by default.

A final order is personal: the person assessed is personally liable for the penalty, and administrators responsible together are jointly and severally liable. The DOL FAQs add that these penalties cannot be paid from plan assets.

After the answer: settlement, decision and appeal

StageWhat the rules sayRule
SettlementJoint motion to defer at least 5 days before the hearing. A consent order waives any further challenge.29 CFR 2570.6529 CFR 2570.65Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
DiscoveryOnly on good cause: a genuine issue of material fact.29 CFR 2570.6629 CFR 2570.66Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
Summary decisionIf no genuine issue of material fact is raised, no hearing is needed.29 CFR 2570.6729 CFR 2570.67Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
DecisionFindings on each material issue; any penalty limited to ERISA 502(c)(2) and supported by reliable and probative evidence.29 CFR 2570.6829 CFR 2570.68Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR
Appeal and reviewNotice of appeal to the Secretary within 20 days. Review is on the record, with no oral argument.29 CFR 2570.6929 CFR 2570.69Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR to 2570.71

The OALJ benchbook (updated January 15, 2021) says the Director of the Office of Policy and Research at EBSA reviews these decisions for the Secretary.

Questions filers ask

How long do I have to respond to a DOL notice of intent to assess a Form 5500 penalty?

30 days from the date of service to file a written statement of reasonable cause under penalties of perjury. If the DOL served the notice by certified mail, service is complete on mailing and you get 5 extra days.

Can I still use the DFVCP after the DOL notice arrives?

No. The DOL FAQs say a Department of Labor notice of intent to assess a penalty will always disqualify a plan. An IRS late-filer letter does not.

Does the penalty keep running while the DOL reviews my statement?

No penalty is assessed for the days from service of the notice of intent until the day after the DOL serves its determination, as long as you filed a timely statement of reasonable cause (29 CFR 2560.502c-2(b)(2))29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR.

Can the DOL's determination be higher than the notice of intent?

No. The amount in the notice of determination cannot exceed the notice of intent (29 CFR 2560.502c-2(g)(1))29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR.

Can the plan pay the penalty?

No. The plan administrator is personally liable, and the DOL says the penalty cannot be paid from plan assets.

Can I get more time to answer?

Do not plan on it. In a case the OALJ benchbook describes, the DOL's notices warned in bold print that the law does not allow extensions of time to respond, and the judge relied on that warning.