Late filing, penalties and relief

Rejected and deficient Form 5500 filings

A Form 5500 can be on time and still count as not filed. EFAST2 screens every filing and assigns a status, and the DOL can later reject a report under ERISA 104(a)(4) as incomplete or for a material qualification in the auditor's opinion. If a satisfactory revised report is not filed within 45 days of the DOL's rejection notice, the report is treated as a failure to file and penalties run from the original due date.

Updated November 20, 2026Sources ERISA 104(a)(4) and (5); ERISA 502(c)(2); 29 CFR 2560.502c-2; 2025 Instructions for Form 5500; EFAST2 Guide for Filers and EFAST2 FAQs

Two layers of review

A Form 5500 is checked twice. First, EFAST2 screens it within minutes of submission and gives it a filing status. Second, the DOL, IRS and PBGC can review it later. The 2025 instructions describe both: your entries must pass the initial electronic screening for the filing to be received, and “Once received, your form may be subject to further detailed review, and your filing may be rejected based upon this further review.”

A clean EFAST2 status is not the end of it. The EFAST2 guide says a filing may be deemed deficient after that later review even if EFAST2 received it without errors.

EFAST2 filing statuses

The EFAST2 Guide for Filers and Service Providers and EFAST2 FAQ 38 explain the statuses. Only some of them count as a filing:

StatusWhat it meansCounts as filed?What to do
Filing ReceivedNo errors, or only possible errors (warnings)YesCorrect anything needed with an amended filing
Filing ErrorEFAST2 found errorsYes, but it contains errorsCorrect and resubmit the entire form as an amended filing
Processing StoppedCrucial information missing, so EFAST2 could not fully check itYes, but it is incompleteCorrect and resubmit the entire form as an amended filing
Filing UnprocessableEFAST2 could not read the returnNoCorrect and resubmit the return
Unprocessable SubmissionEFAST2 could not read any return in the submissionNoCorrect and resubmit the submission
ProcessingStill being read; should not last more than 20 minutesNot yetWait 20 minutes and check again

The guide is clear on the best outcome: “EFAST2 has no status better than Filing Received.” And on the worst: “This annual return/report is not considered filed with the Government.” An Acknowledgment ID alone does not prove the filing was received; EFAST2 FAQ 36 says you must check the status. See EFAST2 acknowledgments and edit tests.

Errors have four severities. A warning leaves the status at Filing Received. An error produces Filing Error. A stop, such as a signature error, makes EFAST2 stop checking and produces Processing Stopped. Unprocessable means EFAST2 could not read the filing at all; the plan name field is blank and the Amend function is not available. The 2025 instructions call the stopped status “Filing_Stopped” when they explain which prior statuses need the amended box checked.

Errors that make a filing incomplete

The 2025 instructions name several defects that lead to rejection or penalties. The signature is the most common:

DefectWhat the source says
No valid plan administrator signatureThe 2025 instructions: “If the plan administrator does not sign a filing, the filing status will indicate that there is an error with your filing”, and the filing faces review, correspondence, rejection and civil penalties. EFAST2 error P-227 flags it.
Missing accountant's opinion on a large planEFAST2 errors P-204 and P-205. EFAST2 receives the filing, but it is incomplete (see below).
Schedule of assets not attached when Schedule H, line 4i is “yes”EFAST2 error P-317.
Welfare plan's Form M-1 questions not answeredFailure to answer line 11a (and 11b and 11c where they apply) or to give a valid Form M-1 receipt code subjects the filing to rejection as incomplete.
A Social Security number on a public part of the filingThe 2025 instructions say it may result in the rejection of the filing.
Wrong form year for the plan yearEFAST2 error X-048. Use the Form 5500 Version Selection Tool.
Late filingEFAST2 warning I-101 (I-101SF, I-101EZ). Check the extension box or the DFVC box, or attach a reasonable cause explanation.

These codes come from the DOL's list of the most common EFAST2 errors, last updated October 31, 2023. It places the DFVC box on line D of the Form 5500 and line C of the Form 5500-SF, which matches the 2025 forms. Check older references against the current year's instructions.

The IFILE guide gives the practical rule: validate each filing and fix the problems before signing, and you can avoid an amendment and the risk of correspondence, rejection and penalties. For signature setup, see EFAST2 signer credentials and Login.gov.

Missing audit reports

A large plan filing Schedule H generally must attach the report of an independent qualified public accountant (IQPA) under ERISA 103(a)(3)(A). See the audit requirement and Schedule H. Leaving it off does not stop the filing from going through, which makes the gap easy to miss. EFAST2 FAQ 25 says: “EFAST2 will receive your filing, but the filing is incomplete without the required IQPA report.” The Schedule H instructions are direct: “If the required IQPA's report is not attached to the Form 5500, the filing is subject to rejection as incomplete and penalties may be assessed.”

If you must file before the audit is done, the FAQ says to correct the error as soon as possible, and you still must answer the Schedule H, line 3 questions about the IQPA correctly. A short plan year of seven months or less can defer the IQPA report under 29 CFR 2520.104-5029 CFR 2520.104-50Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, using the statement the instructions describe.

Missing audit reports are a steady source of DOL penalty cases. The administrative law judges' benchbook lists several. In one, the DOL proposed $43,350, then reduced it by 95 percent to $2,167 after the plan filed its IQPA report, and the judge affirmed the reduced amount. The judge noted that ERISA “places responsibility for accurate, complete, and timely reporting on the plan administrator”. In another, the judge pointed to the administrator's failure to file the audit report within the 45 days the agency allowed. See Form 5500 penalty decisions for more cases.

DOL rejection under ERISA 104(a)(4)

The rejection power is in ERISA 104(a)(4), 29 U.S.C. 1024(a)(4). The Secretary of Labor may reject any filing:

  1. As incomplete: “if he determines that such filing is incomplete for purposes of this part”; or
  2. For a qualified opinion: “if he determines that there is any material qualification by an accountant or actuary contained in an opinion” submitted with the report.

So a report can be rejected even with an audit report attached, if the opinion contains a material qualification. Under ERISA 104(a)(5), if a satisfactory revised filing is not submitted within 45 days and the DOL thinks it is in the participants' best interest, it can hire an independent accountant to audit the plan, hire an enrolled actuary, sue, or take other action. The statute makes the plan liable to the Secretary for the cost of that audit or report.

The penalty statute treats a rejected report as missing. ERISA 502(c)(2) provides that “an annual report that has been rejected under section 1024(a)(4) of this title for failure to provide material information shall not be treated as having been filed with the Secretary” (29 U.S.C. 1132(c)(2)).

The 45-day clock and the penalty

The DOL's penalty regulation, 29 CFR 2560.502c-2, sets the deadline to cure. A rejected report “shall be treated as a failure to file an annual report when a revised report satisfactory to the Department is not filed within 45 days of the date of the Department's notice of rejection”.

What happensResult
Satisfactory revised report filed within 45 days of the rejection noticeNot treated as a failure to file under this rule
No satisfactory revised report within 45 daysTreated as not filed. The penalty is measured from the original due date, without regard to extensions
DOL then serves a notice of intent to assess30 days to file a statement of reasonable cause under penalties of perjury

The penalty can reach $2,739 a day under ERISA 502(c)(2) for penalties assessed after January 15, 2025 (90 FR 1854)90 FR 1854Federal Register, govinfo, with no 2026 adjustment (91 FR 31358)91 FR 31358Federal Register, govinfo. The regulation counts from the original due date, determined without regard to any extension, not from the date the DOL noticed the problem. The benchbook reports a 1994 ruling that rejected a judge's decision to start the penalty on the date the agency first told the plan its reports were deficient.

Do not count on more time. In one benchbook case the judge noted that the notice of rejection and the notice of intent to assess warned in bold print that no extension would be allowed. Another case held that filing an acceptable report after the DOL's notice of determination could not reduce the penalty. For the notice of intent and the reasonable cause statement, see the DOL penalty notice guide and the reasonable cause statement template.

The IRS takes a similar view: its notices page says an incomplete return is not considered filed until it is complete. It says incomplete returns can draw late filing penalties, incomplete penalties, or both, from the IRS and the DOL.

How the DOL contacts you

DOL correspondence about a filing usually arrives by email. EFAST2 FAQ 48 says the DOL uses email for Form 5500 and 5500-SF inquiries and rejections. The first emails come from DRC@dol.gov and go to the email address linked to the plan administrator's electronic signature. If a service provider signed under the e-signature option, the provider may receive them and must pass them on. You can fill in the attached PDF and email it back to DRC@dol.gov. The FAQ adds that the DOL will never ask for your Social Security number, bank account or credit card information by email.

You cannot opt out. FAQ 50 says that if the DOL gets no response to its emails, it may try phone or mail before assessing penalties or fees. Keep the plan administrator's EFAST2 profile and Login.gov email current; FAQ 47 says the DOL, IRS or PBGC may use the contact details of the administrator, sponsor or transmitter.

Curing with an amended filing

Every fix is an amended filing in EFAST2. “An amended filing should be submitted as a complete replacement of the previously submitted filing.” You cannot send only the changed schedule or the missing attachment.

  1. Read the status and the DOL letter. List every error code and every item the DOL asked for.
  2. Fix the whole filing. Correct the form, add the missing IQPA report or schedule, and re-run validation until no errors remain.
  3. Check the amended box. On the Form 5500 or 5500-SF, check the line B box for “an amended return/report” if the earlier filing received a Filing_Received, Filing_Error or Filing_Stopped status. Do not check it if earlier attempts were not received by EFAST2 because of transmission problems.
  4. Sign and submit the complete filing, with every schedule and attachment. Use the same software as the original if you can; IFILE's Amend function links the amendment to the original by its Acknowledgment ID.
  5. Check the new status and answer the DOL within the time it gave, ideally well inside the 45 days.

After an amendment, both filings appear on the EFAST2 Submissions page, and the original keeps its original status. See amending a Form 5500 for prior year rules and form versions.

Why the DFVCP does not cure a deficiency

The DFVC Program is for late and missing reports, not defective ones. The 2002 DOL notice says: “Relief under this Program does not extend to penalties that may be assessed for annual reports that are determined by the Department to be incomplete or otherwise deficient.” DFVC filings go through the usual edit checks, and the DOL's FAQs warn that failing to correct deficiencies under 29 CFR 2560.502c-229 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR can bring further deficient filer penalties. The DFVCP also does not accept amended filings. A filing that was on time but deficient is cured by an amendment and the 45-day process above.

Questions filers ask

Is a Form 5500 with a Filing Error status considered filed?

Yes, but it contains errors and must be corrected through a complete amended filing. Only Filing Unprocessable and Unprocessable Submission are not considered filings.

We filed without the audit report. What now?

EFAST2 received it, but it is incomplete and subject to rejection. Submit an amended filing with the IQPA report as soon as possible; do not wait for a DOL letter.

How long do I have after a DOL rejection notice?

45 days. Under 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(b)(3)29 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, a rejected report is treated as not filed if a satisfactory revised report is not filed within 45 days of the notice.

Can I send just the missing schedule?

No. EFAST2 requires the whole filing to be resubmitted as an amended filing, with all schedules and attachments.

Does the penalty start from the rejection date?

No. 29 CFR 2560.502c-229 CFR 2560.502c-2Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR measures from the original due date, without regard to extensions. A 1994 ruling rejected using the date the agency first flagged the problem.

Can I use the DFVCP to fix a deficient filing?

No. The DFVCP covers late and missing reports. The 2002 DFVC notice says its relief does not extend to reports the DOL finds incomplete or deficient.