The DOL penalty: ERISA 502(c)(2)
The statute is short. “The Secretary may assess a civil penalty against any plan administrator of up to $1,000 a day” from the date of the administrator's failure or refusal to file the annual report (29 U.S.C. 1132(c)(2)). The same paragraph adds that a report rejected for missing material information is not treated as filed.
The $1,000 is adjusted for inflation each year under the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act. For penalties assessed after January 15, 2025, the DOL's 2025 rule (90 FR 1854) sets the ERISA 502(c)(2) maximum at $2,739 a day, up from $2,670. There is no 2026 increase: the DOL's May 27, 2026 notice (91 FR 31358) explains that the October 2025 CPI-U was never published and so “the 2026 adjustment is cancelled entirely”. The 2025 amount stays in place. Older IRS pages still show lower figures, such as $2,259.
The penalty is the plan administrator's. Under 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(j), if more than one person is responsible as administrator, they are jointly and severally liable, and anyone assessed under a final order is personally liable. The DOL's DFVCP FAQs add that civil penalties under ERISA 502(c)(2) cannot be paid from plan assets.
How the DOL assesses it
The regulation, 29 CFR 2560.502c-2, sets the process. The amount is set by the DOL “taking into consideration the degree and/or willfulness of the failure or refusal to file the annual report”, up to the inflation-adjusted daily maximum. A failure to file includes filing only part of the required information.
The clock starts on “the date on which the annual report was due (determined without regard to any extension for filing)”. So a plan that had a valid Form 5558 extension but missed the extended date is measured from the original due date.
In practice, the DOL has described a lower working schedule than the statutory maximum. Both the 2002 DFVC notice and the DOL's 2020 DFVCP FAQs describe it:
| Filer | DOL assessment practice | Counted from |
|---|---|---|
| Late filer (report filed after the due date, including extensions) | $50 a day, with no limit | The original due date, ignoring extensions |
| Non-filer (no report filed) | $300 a day, up to $30,000 a year, until a complete report is filed | The original due date |
| Statutory ceiling | $2,739 a day (2025, 90 FR 1854) | The original due date |
These working amounts are DOL enforcement policy stated in the FAQs, not limits in the regulation. The regulation's only ceiling is the inflation-adjusted daily maximum, and the DOL can assess anything up to it.
Deficient and rejected filings
A report that goes in on time can still be treated as not filed. EFAST2 and the DOL review filings, and a report missing material information can be rejected under ERISA 104(a)(4). The regulation then gives the administrator 45 days: a rejected report “shall be treated as a failure to file an annual report when a revised report satisfactory to the Department is not filed within 45 days of the date of the Department's notice of rejection”. If a satisfactory revised report goes in within the 45 days, the rejected report is not treated as a failure to file under this rule. If it does not, the report is treated as not filed and the penalty is measured from the original due date.
The IRS takes the same view on its side: “An incomplete return isn’t considered filed until it is complete.” See how to file in EFAST2 for the edit tests a filing must pass.
Reasonable cause and hearings
Before assessing, the DOL must send a notice of intent to assess a penalty that states the amount, the period and the reasons. The administrator then has a fixed sequence of deadlines:
- 30 days to file a statement of reasonable cause. From service of the notice, the administrator has 30 days to explain in writing why the penalty should be reduced or not assessed. “The statement must contain a declaration by the administrator that the statement is made under the penalties of perjury.” If service was by certified mail, add 5 days.
- No statement means the facts are admitted. Missing the 30 days “shall be deemed to constitute a waiver of the right to appear and contest the facts alleged in the notice of intent”, and the notice becomes a final order 45 days from service.
- The penalty stops running during review. If a timely reasonable cause statement is filed, no penalty is assessed for the days from service of the notice until the day after the DOL serves its determination.
- The DOL decides. It sends a written determination waiving the penalty in whole or part, or assessing it, in an amount no higher than the notice of intent.
- 30 days to request a hearing. The determination becomes a final order 45 days after service unless, within 30 days, the administrator files a request for a hearing and an answer under 29 CFR 2570.60 to 2570.71 (29 CFR part 2570, subpart C).
The DOL may waive all or part of the penalty if the administrator shows it complied, or shows mitigating circumstances about the degree or willfulness of the failure. A statement of reasonable cause counts as filed when mailed by USPS certified mail or Express Mail, when given to a designated private delivery service, or on receipt by the DOL for other methods.
IRS penalties
The Internal Revenue Code adds separate penalties, imposed on notice and demand and collected like tax. Each has a reasonable cause exception. The amounts below were raised by section 403 of the SECURE Act for returns required to be filed after December 31, 2019.
| Code section | Failure | Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| IRC 6652(e) | Form 5500 series return required under IRC 6058 not filed when due | $250 a day, up to $150,000 per return |
| IRC 6652(d)(1) | Form 8955-SSA (IRC 6057(a) registration statement) not filed or incomplete | $10 per participant per day, up to $50,000 per plan year |
| IRC 6652(d)(2) | Notification of change of plan status (IRC 6057(b)) not filed | $10 a day, up to $10,000 |
| IRC 6692 | Actuarial report (Schedule SB or MB) not filed | $1,000 per failure |
The text of IRC 6652(e) sets the Form 5500 penalty at “$250 for each day during which such failure continues, but the total amount imposed under this subsection on any person for failure to file any return shall not exceed $150,000”. The IRS Form 5500 Corner confirms that the penalty for Form 5500 series returns required by IRC 6058 rose to $250 a day, up to $150,000.
One difference from the DOL rule matters. The IRC 6652(e) period is measured from the due date “(determined with regard to any extension of time for filing)”, so a valid Form 5558 extension moves the IRS start date. The Form 8955-SSA penalty in IRC 6652(d) is the opposite: it is measured without regard to any extension. For defined benefit plans, IRC 6692 imposes $1,000 for each failure to file the actuarial report, unless the failure is due to reasonable cause.
How the DOL and IRS penalties relate
The two agencies' penalties are separate and can both apply to the same late filing. Which ones apply depends on the type of plan. The IRS notices page summarizes it:
| Plan type | IRS penalty | DOL penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Pension plan (401(k), defined benefit, other retirement plans) | Yes | Yes |
| Welfare plan, including welfare and fringe benefit plans | No | Yes |
| Form 5500-EZ filers (one-participant and foreign plans) | Yes | No |
A health and welfare plan faces only the DOL penalty. A one-participant plan filing Form 5500-EZ faces only the IRS penalty, because it is not covered by Title I of ERISA. A 401(k) plan faces both, plus the Form 8955-SSA penalty if it has separated vested participants.
Relief is linked. A Title I filer that completes the DFVCP and files any required Form 8955-SSA on paper gets IRS relief from the IRC 6652(d), 6652(e) and 6692 penalties under Notice 2014-35, without applying for it. The PBGC also agreed in 2002 not to assess its ERISA 4071 late filing penalty where the DFVC conditions are met.
IRS notices filers receive
The IRS's filing notices page explains the letters a Form 5500 filer may see:
| Notice | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| CP403 | Delinquency notice: the IRS has no Form 5500 or 5500-SF for a plan year and shows the plan as active. Mailed 15 months after the original due date. | Check whether you filed and whether the EIN, plan name and plan number match. Respond within 30 days. |
| CP406 | Final delinquency notice, mailed 15 weeks after the CP403 if there is no response and the DOL still has no return. | Complete Section I and return a copy within 30 days. |
| CP216H | Form 5558 extension denied because it was not received on time. | File the Form 5500 series return or Form 8955-SSA at once to limit late penalties. |
| CP216F | Form 5558 extension approved. | Keep the notice and file by the new due date. |
| CP283 | Penalty charged for a late or incomplete Form 5500-EZ. | Pay, or send a signed reasonable cause statement with any missing information. |
The IRS says CP403 and CP406 notices “aren’t bills”; they ask for a missing return. It does not allow extensions to reply. For a Form 5500-EZ, the CP283 page says you can send a signed statement asking for the penalty to be removed if you have an acceptable reason the return was late or incomplete.
Reducing or avoiding penalties
- File on time or extend. Form 5558 must be filed by the normal due date. The DOL clock still runs from the original date if you miss the extended date.
- Use the DFVCP before the DOL writes. The DFVCP caps the DOL amount at $750 or $2,000 per filing and $1,500 or $4,000 per plan, and only works until the DOL notifies you in writing. A CP403 from the IRS does not close it.
- File Form 8955-SSA on paper with the DFVC filing. That is the condition for IRS relief under Notice 2014-35.
- Fix rejections within 45 days. A corrected report filed within 45 days of a DOL rejection notice avoids the failure-to-file treatment.
- Answer a DOL notice within 30 days. A reasonable cause statement under penalties of perjury preserves your rights and stops the daily penalty during review.
- For Form 5500-EZ, use the IRS program. The DFVCP is not available; the IRS has its own late filer program and reasonable cause relief.
Criminal penalties
The 2025 instructions also list penalties that require a conviction: a fine of up to $100,000, up to 10 years in prison, or both for a willful violation of Part 1 of Title I of ERISA (ERISA 501), and up to $10,000, five years in prison, or both for knowingly making a false statement or concealing a fact required by ERISA (18 U.S.C. 1027). The administrative penalties above apply unless the failure to file properly is for reasonable cause.
Questions filers ask
How much is the DOL penalty for a late Form 5500 in 2026?
Up to $2,739 a day under ERISA 502(c)(2). That is the 2025 amount from 90 FR 1854; the DOL made no adjustment for 2026 (91 FR 31358).
Does a Form 5558 extension change when penalties start?
For the DOL, no: 29 CFR 2560.502c-2 counts from the original due date if you file after the extended date. For the IRS Form 5500 penalty under IRC 6652(e), the due date is determined with regard to the extension.
Do welfare plans face IRS penalties?
The IRS notices page shows the IRS penalty applying to pension plans and Form 5500-EZ filers, and the DOL penalty applying to pension and welfare plans. A welfare plan faces the DOL penalty.
Is a CP403 a penalty?
No. The IRS says CP403 and CP406 notices are not bills. They ask for a missing Form 5500 or 5500-SF. Respond within 30 days.
Can the plan pay the penalty?
Not the DOL penalty. The plan administrator is personally liable under 29 CFR 2560.502c-2(j), and the DOL says these penalties cannot be paid from plan assets.
What if the DOL already sent a notice of intent to assess?
The DFVCP is no longer available for those filings. File any missing report, and file a reasonable cause statement within 30 days of service of the notice.