- The general rule
- The small unfunded or insured exemption
- What makes a plan funded
- Large insured and unfunded plans
- Plans funded through a trust or VEBA
- Counting welfare participants
- Schedule A for insured benefits
- Wrap plans: one plan or several
- Cafeteria plans
- Stopping and restarting: codes 4R and 4S
- MEWAs and Form M-1
The general rule
The 2025 instructions start from a filing duty: “All welfare benefit plans covered by ERISA are required to file a Form 5500 except as provided in this section.” Welfare plans include plans that provide medical, dental, life insurance, disability, severance pay, apprenticeship and training, scholarship and similar benefits.
Most small employer health plans never file, because of one exemption. The DOL fact sheet on the 2023 changes says that, of an estimated 2.5 million health plans, only 63,000 filed a 2020 Form 5500, because “Welfare plans with fewer than 100 participants that are unfunded or insured (do not hold assets in trust) are generally exempt from filing a Form 5500.”
The small unfunded or insured exemption
Under 29 CFR 2520.104-20, the administrator of a qualifying small welfare plan “is not required to file with the Secretary an annual or terminal report”. The plan must meet every condition:
- Fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year.
- Benefits paid as needed from the general assets of the employer or employee organization, or provided exclusively through insurance contracts or an HMO, or both.
- For insured benefits, premiums paid directly to the insurer by the employer, with any participant contributions forwarded within three months of receipt.
- For an insured plan, refunds owed to contributing participants returned within three months, and participants told on entry how refunds are allocated.
- The plan is not subject to the Form M-1 requirements for multiple employer welfare arrangements.
The count is taken once, at the start of the year. In the regulation's own example, a plan with 75 participants at the beginning of the year and 105 at the end stays exempt “because it had fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year”.
The exemption covers the annual report and the summary annual report, not the rest of ERISA. It does not lift the duty to furnish the summary plan description, to give documents to the DOL on request, or the other Title I rules.
What makes a plan funded
This is where many small plans lose the exemption. An unfunded plan pays benefits directly from the employer's general assets. The instructions warn that “Plans that are NOT unfunded include those plans that received employee (or former employee) contributions during the plan year and/or used a trust or separately maintained fund” to hold or pass through plan assets.
A fully insured plan may take employee contributions toward premiums, as long as the employer pays the insurer directly and forwards the contributions within three months. A plan that holds assets in a trust, or a self-insured medical plan that takes employee contributions, is neither unfunded nor fully insured for this test and cannot use the 29 CFR 2520.104-20 exemption. For the self-insured plan with employee contributions, the cafeteria plan relief below is the way back to unfunded treatment.
Large insured and unfunded plans
When an unfunded or insured welfare plan reaches 100 participants at the beginning of the year, it must file. 29 CFR 2520.104-44 gives it a lighter report. The regulation's example of a fully insured plan with 100 or more participants says “such a welfare plan should file Form 5500, including Schedule A”, and that it “is not required to engage an independent qualified public accountant”.
The instructions add that neither Schedule H nor an accountant's opinion is attached for such a plan. “However, Schedule G, Part III, must be attached to the Form 5500 to report any nonexempt transactions.” The regulation is relief from parts of the report, not from filing: its limitation paragraph says it does not exempt any plan from filing an annual report.
| Welfare plan | Participants at start of year | What it files |
|---|---|---|
| Unfunded, fully insured or both | Under 100 | Nothing (29 CFR 2520.104-20), unless it must file Form M-1 |
| Unfunded, fully insured or both | 100 or more | Form 5500, Schedule A for insured benefits, Schedule C if applicable, Schedule G Part III for nonexempt transactions; no Schedule H, no audit |
| Funded (trust or employee contributions held) | Under 100 | Form 5500 with Schedule I, or Form 5500-SF if eligible; no audit |
| Funded (trust or employee contributions held) | 100 or more | Form 5500 with Schedule H, IQPA report and the other large plan schedules |
Plans funded through a trust or VEBA
A welfare plan that holds assets in a trust files under the ordinary large and small plan rules. A large funded plan files Schedule H and attaches the accountant's report, and the instructions say a plan that uses a voluntary employees' beneficiary association (VEBA) under Code section 501(c)(9) “is generally not exempt from the requirement of engaging an IQPA”.
A small funded plan has no audit to worry about. The 5500-SF instructions say welfare plans with fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year are exempt from the annual audit requirement. Such a plan files Form 5500 with Schedule I, or Form 5500-SF if all its assets are eligible plan assets and it meets the other short form conditions. See which Form 5500 to file.
Counting welfare participants
Welfare plans count people differently from retirement plans. An individual becomes a participant on the earliest of the date the plan says participation begins, the date the individual becomes eligible for a benefit, or the date the individual makes a contribution. Former employees on COBRA continuation coverage count. “Covered dependents are not counted as participants.” A child covered under a qualified medical child support order is not counted either. Welfare plans complete only lines 5, 6a(1), 6a(2), 6b, 6c and 6d of the Form 5500.
The 100-participant line also decides whether a filing plan needs an audit. See the audit requirement and the 80-120 rule, which applies to welfare plans that already file.
Schedule A for insured benefits
Any welfare plan that files and has benefits provided by an insurer, Blue Cross Blue Shield or an HMO attaches a Schedule A for each contract. Report the contract year that ends with or within the plan year. Three things do not go on Schedule A:
- An administrative services only (ASO) contract, a fidelity bond or a fiduciary liability policy.
- Stop-loss coverage bought by the employer as the insured, with premiums paid only from the employer's general assets, is generally not a plan asset and is not reported. A stop-loss policy that is a plan asset goes on Part III, line 8i.
- A contract already reported on the Form 5500 of an MTIA or 103-12 IE that holds it.
Insurers must give the administrator what is needed: under ERISA section 103(a)(2) the insurer must provide the information needed to complete Schedule A, though not necessarily on a Schedule A itself. If a carrier refuses, check Yes on line 11 and describe what is missing on line 12.
Wrap plans: one plan or several
Count participants only after you know how many plans you have. The instructions say “The fact that you have separate insurance policies for each different welfare benefit does not necessarily mean that you have separate plans.” Some sponsors use a wrap document to pull several benefits and insurance policies into one comprehensive plan.
A wrap plan files one Form 5500 under one plan number, lists each benefit with welfare feature codes (4A health, 4B life, 4D dental, 4E vision, 4H long-term disability and so on), and attaches a Schedule A for each insurance contract. The instructions describe the practice directly: “Some plan sponsors use a "wrap" document to incorporate various benefits and insurance policies into one comprehensive plan.” The instructions say you must review the governing documents and actual operations, and that single-plan status for Form 5500 can differ from HIPAA, COBRA and tax purposes.
Cafeteria plans
Employee contributions normally make a welfare plan funded. The instructions carve out cafeteria plans: a welfare plan with employee contributions “that is associated with a cafeteria plan under Code section 125 may be treated for annual reporting purposes as an unfunded welfare plan if it meets the requirements of DOL Technical Release 92-01”. The instructions also say that receiving COBRA contributions or other after-tax contributions, such as retiree contributions, does not by itself take away that relief.
So a small health plan paid partly through pre-tax salary reductions under a Section 125 plan can still use the under-100 exemption if it meets the Technical Release conditions. The Form 5500 instructions do not restate the Technical Release conditions, so read TR 92-01 itself before relying on the relief.
Stopping and restarting: codes 4R and 4S
Welfare plans move in and out of the filing duty as headcount changes. Feature code 4R marks an unfunded or insured plan that will not file for the next plan year under 29 CFR 2520.104-20, and code 4S marks one that stopped filing in an earlier year under that rule and is filing again. Do not check the final return box when you enter 4R; the plan is not ending, only its filing duty. If the count later returns to 100 or more, the plan resumes filing and enters 4S.
MEWAs and Form M-1
A welfare plan that provides benefits through a multiple employer welfare arrangement must file unless otherwise exempt, and a plan required to file Form M-1 cannot use the small plan exemption at all. The instructions say plans required to file Form M-1 must file the Form 5500 regardless of plan size or type of funding. The other welfare plans that do not file (governmental, church, top hat, workers' compensation and plans covered by a group insurance arrangement's filing) are listed on plans that do not file Form 5500.
Questions filers ask
Does a fully insured group health plan with 40 employees file Form 5500?
Generally no. A welfare plan with fewer than 100 participants at the beginning of the plan year that is fully insured, with employee contributions forwarded to the insurer within three months, is exempt under 29 CFR 2520.104-20, unless it must file Form M-1.
Our insured plan has 150 participants. Do we need an audit?
No. A fully insured, unfunded or combination plan with 100 or more participants files Form 5500 with Schedule A, but under 29 CFR 2520.104-44 it does not engage an independent accountant or file Schedule H. It must still report nonexempt transactions on Schedule G, Part III.
Are spouses and children counted as participants?
No. The instructions say covered dependents are not counted. Former employees on COBRA coverage are counted.
Does a self-insured plan with employee contributions qualify as unfunded?
Generally not, because employee contributions make a plan funded for this purpose. The exception is a plan tied to a Section 125 cafeteria plan that meets DOL Technical Release 92-01.
Do we file one Form 5500 per insurance policy?
Not necessarily. The number of filings follows the number of plans, not policies, and the instructions note that some sponsors use a wrap document to bring several benefits and policies into one plan, which then files one Form 5500 with a Schedule A for each insurance contract.
Do ASO fees go on Schedule A?
No. Schedule A is not filed for an administrative services only contract.